
Liberty Counsel sets the standard about as low as can be in determining which retailers qualify for its “nice” rating in its “naughty or nice” listing of retailers as they promote their products or services at this time of year: All that is necessary is to use the word “Christmas,” even minimally, on the company’s website rather always using more neutral terms such as “season” or “holidays” to refer to this gift-buying period.
But, still, a fair number of retailers don’t make the “nice” list.
Liberty Counsel, a Christian ministry that focuses almost entirely on litigation relating to religious liberty, has been publishing its list annually as part of what it calls its Friend or Foe Christmas Campaign. This year’s list is the 24th — and Liberty Counsel offered both praise and scorn, respectively, to those companies that shift from “naughty” to “nice” or the opposite.
The organization noted, for example, that Walmart used to order its employees not to say “Merry Christmas” to shoppers, but now Walmart is consistently on the “nice” list. It also said that three years ago Target was on the “naughty” list “for going ‘all in’ on woke ‘pride’ decorations that mocked the Christmas holiday” but has now earned a place on the “nice” list.
In terms of changes from last year’s list to the 2026 one, Liberty Counsel said that Barnes & Noble and Big Lots have made the “nice” cut. But Belk and Best Buy have moved to the “naughty” list because they “took a nearly sterilized approach to ‘Christmas’ in their online holiday campaigns as compared to prior years.”
In total, 28 retailers qualified for the “nice” list while 18 were deemed “naughty.” A complete list of Liberty Counsel’s ratings can be found here.
Although retailers have the constitutional right to ignore or refer to Christmas however the wish, Liberty Counsel pointed out in its announcement why it matters what retailers do:
Christianity remains the largest faith tradition in the United States. Christmas is both a religious holiday and a cultural tradition for Christians and is associated with worship, family traditions, nostalgia, generosity, and seasonal joy. When Christmas language, symbols, and decorations are removed, it can be viewed as society’s hostile push to marginalize the Christian identity and remove faith from public life. While corporate intentions may invoke political correctness, their displays of holiday neutrality divide rather than unify because it removes the meaningful celebration, community traditions, and joyous expression many religious Americans want at Christmastime.
Under a headline that said “You can help us save Christmas,” Liberty Counsel said it encourages those who support its mission to patronize companies on the “nice” list and to politely explain to those on the “naughty” list why they are shopping elsewhere.

